The used car market is booming. With new vehicle prices averaging over $50,000, many buyers are turning to pre-owned options to avoid steep depreciation and still get reliable transportation. While risk exists in buying used, certain brands consistently outperform others in dependability and value retention. This guide identifies eight automakers known for producing excellent used vehicles, ranked by model diversity.
Why this matters: The rising cost of new cars means more consumers are relying on the used market. Knowing which brands hold up best over time can save buyers money and headaches. A well-maintained used car from a dependable manufacturer is often a smarter financial move than a new vehicle that loses value rapidly.
8. Buick (4 Models)
Buick has quietly become the top-ranking American brand for used car reliability, according to J.D. Power’s 2025 Vehicle Dependability Study. The brand’s focus on crossovers – the most popular vehicle type in the U.S. – simplifies the buying process. With just four models and three trim options each, Buick offers straightforward choices.
Key takeaway: Used Buicks are dependable and well-priced due to depreciation on already competitive new prices. The 2022 Buick Enclave and the smaller Encore are popular choices.
7. Subaru (9 Models)
Subaru’s reputation for durability extends to the used market. The brand’s iconic boxer engines and standard all-wheel drive make it a favorite in regions with harsh weather or rough road conditions. Models like the Forester and Outback are highly sought after, and the Solterra EV adds value.
Context: Subaru’s close partnership with Toyota enhances its appeal, but the brand stands on its own merits. Its competitive pricing translates into excellent used car deals.
6. Mazda (9 Models)
Mazda has carved a niche for itself by offering stylish, sporty vehicles without sacrificing quality. Ranked just behind Buick on the J.D. Power Dependability Index, Mazda provides a compelling mix of design, performance, and reliability. Six of its nine models are SUVs and crossovers, catering to current consumer preferences.
Why it matters: Mazda’s commitment to design and driving experience sets it apart. Used buyers get a stylish car at a good price without compromising dependability.
5. Honda (10 Models)
Honda consistently ranks among the best-selling brands in the U.S., and its used vehicles are no exception. The CR-V crossover rivals the Toyota RAV4 in popularity, while the Civic remains a strong choice for buyers seeking a fuel-efficient sedan or hatchback.
The Honda advantage: Known for dependability and value retention, Honda holds its own in the J.D. Power index. Models like the Civic and Ridgeline keep their value well.
4. Lexus (11 Models)
Lexus, Toyota’s luxury division, is consistently ranked as the most dependable brand by J.D. Power. While it doesn’t match Mercedes-Benz or BMW in performance, Lexus offers superior value retention and reliability at a competitive price.
Key benefit: Hybrid systems perfected over 25 years ensure long-term dependability. Six SUVs and several luxury sedans cater to discerning buyers.
3. Hyundai (12 Models)
Hyundai has undergone a transformation in the last decade, improving engineering and manufacturing quality. Models like the Tucson, Santa Fe, and Palisade now offer reliability alongside advanced technology and comprehensive warranties.
What to know: Hyundai’s warranties often extend to used vehicles, giving buyers peace of mind. The Ioniq 5 and Ioniq 6 EVs were both World Car of the Year winners.
2. Kia (12 Models)
Kia has emerged as a major player in the reliability stakes, challenging Toyota, Honda, and Mazda. High levels of standard luxury tech and strong safety ratings make its vehicles attractive to used car buyers.
Why Kia stands out: Excellent warranties and a wide range of drivetrains, including hybrid and EV options, provide flexibility. The Kia Sportage is a popular choice for its value and versatility.
1. Toyota (20 Models)
Toyota remains the gold standard for quality, reliability, and value retention. Decades of consistent performance make it the most sought-after brand in the used car market. Toyota’s pioneering hybrid technology ensures fuel efficiency and long-term dependability.
The Toyota edge: An enormous range of vehicles caters to all needs, from large SUVs to compact cars. Buyers get Toyota peace of mind without compromising on vehicle type.
Final Thoughts: The used car market offers significant savings, but choosing the right brand is crucial. Toyota, Kia, Hyundai, and Lexus consistently deliver reliability and value retention, making them ideal choices for smart buyers seeking dependable transportation.
